Notes

Lacrymocracy

A dispatch on the recent uprisings in France from poet and writer Nathalie Quintane, one of the leading voices of the French literary left. 

Nathalie Quintane19 November 2026

Lacrymocracy

Nathalie Quintane is one of the leading voices of the French literary left. In this new dispatch for Verso Notes, she reports from the recent uprisings in France.  

Morning, October 6, Digne-les-Bains, Basses-Alpes, France. The students’ Act III.[1] School blockades are scheduled for 8 a.m.; I’m running a little behind. The technical high school and the general high school were built across from each other on the same avenue, with speed bumps and bollards throughout to prohibit parking. The kids from working-class and local middle-class families rarely talk to each other, having  been carefully sorted into different high schools at the end of their middle school years, but here, since October 2, when a pile of pallets was set ablaze right in the middle of the road, they meet. ’68, after all, had made its way even to the middle schools, and the apprentice rebellion in the early ’70s had been decisive—and violently suppressed. I finally arrive by the high schools. I can’t see anything. It’s empty. Where are they? I start to look for the protest. That’s it—I have to look for the protest. That it’s frustrating is a good sign: in the last ten years, these things have often been decided at the last moment, without the involvement of the prefecture or the major unions. So begins a so-called “wildcat protest”—a fast, free-flowing rush through the city that wears out the cops and delights the protesters. Someone says, “How about we go that way instead?” and we’re off! I quickly check my WhatsApp: it looks like the crowd has joined another high school three kilometers away. That’s far. I get annoyed. I would look for them again that day and never quite find them—only a few, toward the end, gathered beneath the union banners outside the local school inspectorate. 

A cop warns them that they should under no circumstances pick up a stun grenade from the ground—a 15-year-old boy had just had his hand blown off in Lens. The same people who for years have been using and abusing so-called non-lethal or “intermediate” weapons, which maim and blind indiscriminately (25 eyes lost among the Yellow Vests, 5 hands blown off), are perfectly capable of explaining to their potential future victims what not to do. France is a pedagogical country. Macron has repeated throughout his terms in office that if we do not understand the government’s decisions, it is because the government has failed to explain them clearly. The French are a people schooled from the cradle to the grave. Prince Macron dreams of a nation of schoolchildren. But this time, it was the schoolchildren who revolted, and no one saw it coming. No one. The left, of course, had been wondering when the students would finally get involved, the students, a third of whom are starving and wearing themselves out in dead-end jobs just to pay their rent. Students, bring us another May ’68! The surprise was tremendous, up there with the surprise provoked by the Yellow Vests, those a priori apolitical, “impure” non-people who dared to declare themselves a people across the country’s crossroads without seeking anyone’s permission. The ones who don’t matter and the ones no one counts. And God knows kids don’t matter in this country! Oh, sure, a few scandals have brought them back to our minds in recent years: all those Catholic schools where they were raped, all those cases of incest that were kept quiet for as long as anyone could remember so as not to upset families and the justice system, to keep the country calm, all those kids from child welfare services stuck in seedy hotels and forced into prostitution with no one left to look after them. All the veneer and hypocrisy of adult rhetoric, compounded by the usual clichés about “coddled children” wasting their time on their phones and not knowing how to read. Then there's Parcoursup, the famous “reform” from President Macron's Education Minister Blanquer, which completely upset class schedules, made class sizes explode, introduced previously unheard-of subjects (the HGGSP “specialization” of History-Geography-Geopolitics and Political Science…) and placed unbearable pressure on high school students throughout the year in order to better screen them after the BAC, reduce university enrollment, and cut their funding. Not to speak of those rats roaming around the banlieue[2] schools… the sweltering months of May and June spent in crumbling and poorly insulated buildings… Lacrymocracy…

It was, finally, the high school students from Mayotte at the end of August and then the banlieues who rang the bell on recess as early as September, marking the end of a relatively inert social climate and the inevitable halt of those family-friendly protests, the ones we marched in with strollers or walkers, waving red flags, the scent of fries with sausages—the famous "CGT hot dogs"— wafting in the air.

Saturday, October 17, I am in Marseille. I already know I won’t be able to take part in the protest, which is shaping up to be massive. Why? Because you have to be able to run fast, and I’m sixty-two years old. Because you have to be properly equipped, mask, goggles, PPE, if you don’t want to choke or get seriously hurt. I head down toward La Canebière, the main avenue in Marseille; it must be around 10 a.m. The usual long line of CRS buses. A huge pile of pallets and electric scooters on fire in the middle of the street. I take a parallel street, which seems less dangerous, and press my scarf against my nose: even three hundred meters away, the tear gas is unbearable (we learn later on that the cops had exhausted part of their stockpile from the beginning and would run out of grenades by the afternoon). I pass Belzunce and the Centre Bourse, the large shopping district with all the metal shutters rolled down. I’m nearing the Vieux Port.

Suddenly, in the distance, I notice a crowd suffocating in tear gas. And, just as suddenly, the crowd starts to run, the cops following close behind. The crowd begins to split, and a small contingent makes its way straight toward me! I rush with others into the lobby of a fortunately open building. We wait. There are protesters retreating. I spot a friend walking past me on the street. He’s carrying a large plastic bag. He points to a man sitting on the steps in the lobby and asks me, “What’s wrong with him?” I turn around. A long trickle of blood runs down from the man’s forehead to his chin. He looks shell-shocked. A baton charge, no doubt. My friend offers him a sandwich from his bag. I attempt an exit. A medic catches his breath at the door. Holding a large bottle half-filled with an opaque white liquid, he explains that it’s for the tear gas. I step outside. I continue my way down to the Vieux Port.

That day, I head home early, after making three or four runs to protected street corners, in a city which feels more electric than ever. The Lundi matin report[3] provides an accurate summary of the events of October 17: It was the “revenge of the children”; it was a matter of righting wrongs. Exacting revenge for the point-blank LBD[4] shots, the broken jaws, the beatings, the injuries, the fear. And for some, a matter of righting a different October 17, the one in 1961, when the cops massacred and threw into the Seine the Algerian demonstrators who had come to peacefully protest a curfew targeted against them. Behind one date, there always lies another date, another event being (re)called, leading back to the founding event — the Yellow Vests’ wooden and cardboard guillotines call back to 1789, the effigies of Macron have been hanging ever since, beaten with clubs to make hundreds of fake banknotes fly as they fall, the calls to burn down the Élysée, to occupy the billionaires’ mansions, to at last rush to western Paris where they cluster and which is tacitly off-limits to popular protest.

And yet, each time there is something new, something unprecedented. This fall, it was Gen Z that picked up the torch. I find their inventiveness, their references, disorienting. I stand there, trying to understand Akatsuki.[5] Who is Monkey D., the character with the straw hat?[6] And then the wordplay—the tough-to-translate punchlines—that populate the signs, those pieces of cardboard held in outstretched arms at high school gates and in protests: “La police nous prothese” “Les feux de poubelle ne font peur qu’aux ordures”… The tag, near the Réformés in Marseille: “Abis la pola” (Down with the police) ACAB is their real, big slogan, a rallying cry); the street sign with “Boulevard Dugommier” changed to “Boulevard Du peuple.” In Digne, a few years ago, the infamous Boulevard Thiers, named after a killer of Communards, was transformed with just a piece of paper and glue into Boulevard Louise Michel. Every friend I’ve spoken to since the protests began shares in the feeling that this movement is filled with exceptional joy, humor, and energy.[7]

By mid-October, there are nearly 8,000 people in police custody, 85% of whom are minors—a level of police and judicial enforcement far greater than during the Yellow Vests protests over an equivalent period. Social media posts document acts of humiliation and beatings in police custody—like the young boy forced to eat a piece of ham on all fours (the French police’s Islamophobia is no great secret: stun grenades inscribed with the word “pig” were recently recovered). On October 18, immediately following a historic, near-insurrectionary day, Macron was readying to declare a state of emergency. He was apparently advised not to do so under any circumstances, arguing it would be too damaging on the economy and tourism. He appears on television, the talking head, nothing out of the ordinary — how many times have we watched him do this over the past ten years? The rehearsed conviction, the clumsy repetition, the wide-eyed gaze, as if induced to a state of auto-hypnosis. Macron is Schrödinger’s cat: he is there and he is not. And he has a talent for articulating the contradictions he creates for himself; contradictions that become the contradictory injunctions he imposes on us: “Your demands are legitimate,” he declares… after having systematically refused to meet any demand whatsoever. And always pitting one group of people against another—in this case, the “rioters” against the “peaceful protesters.” But this doesn’t work anymore. This hasn’t worked for a long time.

I remember the moment, at the beginning of the Nuits Debout[8] protests in 2016, when a very young man emerged from the crowd to reject a request for negotiations from a Paris City Hall representative, stating: “We are done negotiating! We are done participating! It’s over!” The next day saw the beginning of the occupation of Place de la République, which lasted over three months. It was this categorical refusal that I encountered again on October 30 at the foot of the stairs at Marseille’s Saint-Charles Station, on the officially sanctioned banner of the French Communist Party: “Our rights are not negotiable / We want to live in dignity.” It took years for this message—better phrased as “You can’t negotiate with a baton”—to rise from the grassroots to the leadership of the labor unions and political parties, including LFI.[9] The beginning of the end of the people’s great patience is made clear with a resounding NO. On October 18, 2026, Macron did not, ultimately, declare a state of emergency—that state of exception established in 1955 at the start of the Algerian War. That war is an unspoken history that continues to haunt the entire social fabric; an unspoken history that virtually the entire political class exploits, even if the National Rally (formerly the National Front) is the champion of this kind of electoral cynicism. No official state of emergency, but a de facto partial state of emergency: at least two of the five main official measures have been reintroduced: restrictions on movement and the imposition of curfews (particularly for minors, with the final decision lying with local mayors and administrators); house arrest or “preventive” incarceration—as in the case of Ritchy Thibault, a remarkable 22-year-old orator from the Traveler community, jailed for nearly a month for a speech he gave at one of the first major protests, an inflammatory speech which the authorities pretended to interpret literally…

As of the day I write, November 6, 2026, no clear outcome in sight. The call for a strike and the protests on November 5 drew massive participation, prompting the government to convene a “social conference” on purchasing power and wages. In addressing “workers” and only workers, the government is ignoring students, a gesture that could not be more humiliating since the social movement was born out of their efforts, continues largely thanks to them, and possesses unprecedented power precisely because they demanded it. Yet adults, when faced with the young, are like chickens facing a knife. It is when Power, the Powers that be, find themselves in this unpleasant position, when they are the chickens, that we can become the knife (or rather, it is because we are the knife that they become the chickens!), and it is through action that the young (wheather, French, European, international) substantiate the metaphor. We—left-wing adults—respond generally pessimistically or relatively optimistically depending on current events and the prevailing mood. People of color, young and adult alike, especially after the Trappes attack[10], cannot help but be pessimistic: their words echo Baldwin’s when he explains that he left the United States because its racial burden became unbearable to him. A Black person in France, an Arab—even if born in the country—cannot leave their home without fearing that a stupid or crazy white person will beat them or shoot at them.

Eugénie Mérieau, a lawyer and constitutional scholar specializing in states of emergency[11], sees the government’s latest measures as the standard operating procedure of authoritarian regimes, or those on the path to becoming one: “The aim is to make LFI [a left-wing party viewed as radical by the right] appear responsible for what happened…,” she explains, referring to the riots and looting of October 17, “and so, to save the Republic, the LFI must be dissolved—since it incites chaos and violence— everyone will have to be declared ineligible… the state of emergency will have to be incorporated into ordinary law, implemented in various and diverse ways across all cities,” until the elections—whether called early or not—which will inevitably see the right (whether mainstream or far-right; the line between them is blurred) prevail… A social-democratic historian like Patrick Boucheron offers more or less the same analysis. What remains are the unknowns. The unknowns are those children, those teenagers barely of legal age, whose desires are neither measurable nor quantifiable. In Marseille, they cut the opening lines of the national anthem, the aptly named “Marseillaise,” also the opening refrain of the chant sung by supporters of Olympique, the city’s famous soccer club (“To arms! / We are the Marseillais / And we will win! / Go OM!”). Striding through the tear gas, the lacrymocracy, they sing only: “To arms! To arms!” Ad lib.

Translated by Leonor Grave.


[1] The movement has adopted the division into acts that the Yellow Vests (2018–2019) imposed on the government at the time.

[2] The movement started in late August in Mayotte, then spread to French Guiana, to protest overcrowded classrooms and a lack of resources. On September 18, a teachers’ strike began, followed by a blockade of the Saint-Exupéry High School in Créteil (a Paris banlieue), which was shared 1.5 million times on TikTok.

[4] Lanceur de Balle de Défense : a so-called non-lethal weapon, first used by specialized units to combat crime and terrorism in the 1990s, then during the banlieur riots, and finally against the general population beginning in the 2000s.

[5] Akatsuki : Name of the main criminal organization in Naruto.

[6] Character from the manga One Piece.

[7] “Since I’m getting on in years and was myself involved in protest movements when I was young, I’ve noticed that the younger generations’ methods of protest are much more creative and joyful than they were when I was 20.” (Enzo Traverso, in an interview with the Mediapart website on November 5, 2026).

[8] French social movement akin to the Occupy movement.

[9] La France Insoumise, Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s party, which, according to the latest polls, is expected to advance to the second round of the presidential election against Marine Le Pen.

[10] Trappes Attack (Paris region): A racially motivated mass shooting that killed one man and injured five other people, including a 12-year-old girl, on October 23, 2026.

Book strip #1